Merit salary is a clip of employee power management. What room the benefits and limitations that merit pay, and also how have the right to you usage it to drive her company's success?


Merit pay and also incentive pay are both varieties of pay for performance.

You are watching: What is an advantage of bonuses over merit-based pay plan?

A research by researchers at the Wisconsin institution of company found that:

More 보다 90% of carriers use some form of pay for performance.The most common types are merit pay (annual increases) and also bonuses.Both merit and incentive pay improve employee performance.Bonuses have a lot greater impact on performance 보다 merit pay.Performance-based pay has the highest affect in tasks where outcomes are quickly measured.

Bonuses and also other catalyst pay might outperform merit pay due to the fact that of your size. According to the most recent compensation data indigenous Mercer, incentive or promotion pay averaged 9.3% in 2019, while merit pay average 2.9%.


Annual merit boosts averaged 2.9% in 2019. Source:

A 10% bonus will grab much more attention than a 3% annual salary bump, even though the 3% compounds year after year. Add to the the underwhelming performance of the traditional performance review. Gallup reports they often do an ext harm 보다 good, and the ideal path forward is much from clean if you desire to incentivize employee performance.

Here room some merit salary pros and cons come consider.

4 benefits of giving merit pay

Merit salary is a clip of employee engagement and also performance management. Below are some benefits of including a merit pay plan in your compensation and benefits strategy.

1. Rewards high performers

High performers prosper on results, feedback, and also notching wins. They want to check out the numbers go up, the project come in early, the five-star reviews roll in. Tying their pay come those outcomes demonstrates the worth they bring and drives castle to save excelling. To high performers, the yearly performance bonus reinforces their belief that their work matters, and you worth it.

2. Connects work-related to results

To do an excellent things, you must aim because that them. A merit pay system offers clear missions to occupational toward, keeps employee on monitor throughout the year, and rewards them as soon as they attain their goals.

3. Retains great employees

Merit and incentive pay boost employee satisfaction, engagement, and retention. They are specifically important because that retaining optimal performers. Merit pay is likewise a vital factor in recruitment.

4. Boosts performance

A great merit pay program gives employees the tools, incentive, and feedback to strive because that results and improvement. That translates to stronger results and also a stronger company.

4 flaw of providing merit pay

Merit pay likewise has many drawbacks that deserve to reduce or even erase the benefits. Here are four disadvantages to consider when weighing merit-based compensation.

1. Outcomes aren"t constantly measurable

While part goals can be boiled under to measurable vital performance signs (KPIs), many aspects of performance space subjective. Soft an abilities such together communication and also teamwork are not measurable, yet they"re simply as vital to your company"s success as technical competence. Finding objective ways to prize those skills can be challenging.

2. Performance is subjective

Employee power is even harder to appropriately quantify and also measure. All also often, employees feel their ratings are arbitrary, inaccurate, or unfair. Inconsistency native manager to manager have the right to further speak to the same of her system into question.

Many companies have addressed this by removed numeric ratings from power evaluations, but the bottom line still comes under to numbers as soon as you analyze all that feedback right into merit-based raises.

3. That can develop tunnel vision

Merit pay have the right to encourage employee to focus too strictly on the purposes they"re gift rewarded for. This have the right to limit their capacity to explore brand-new ideas and also develop their complete potential. Because that example, a shop floor supervisor who merit boosts are tied to productivity might overlook methods to enhance safety or quality.

4. Rivalry is inevitable

Competition deserve to be healthy. That can likewise destroy a team or a department. An annual trip to Cancun because that your peak salespeople is great, yet employees who miss the note may feel cheated. Is their territory much less desirable? are they acquiring an also chance in ~ the ideal leads? even private performance reviews can come to be a point of contention if employees compare notes on your raises. We"re just human; comes in second, or tenth, hurts.

On the upper and lower reversal side, lucrative poor performers at the exact same level as various other employees have the right to demotivate high achievers.

Nobody stated this would be easy.

Is merit pay best for her business?

Studies confirm merit pay and also other PFP programs can improve employee performance, so, imperfect as it may be, linking salary to performance renders sense. And also with 90% of service providers offering yearly merit increases, skipping them can damage your capability to recruit and retain top performers.

So how have the right to you enjoy the benefits of performance-based pay there is no cries that unfairness?


Promotional boosts or motivation pay average 9.3% in 2019. Source:

9 merit pay system finest practices

Here are ideal practices because that a merit pay device that will occupational for your company and staff.

1. Focus on measurable goals

Tying employee goals to firm performance is a proven tactic for boosting performance and building belief in your pay practices. Usage measurable KPIs where you can. Because that example, rather of rating customer service from "outstanding" come "needs improvement," you could set a bar for hopeful reviews got or tickets closed within 24 hours.

Your system won"t be perfect — they never ever are — yet the an ext you can connect performance come measurable company goals, the much better it will certainly be received.

2. Provide coaching

Are friend investing in employee training and development? Employees want to learn and grow in ~ work. Providing them opportunities to upskill and also improve is critical to helping them achieve company goals.

3. Give regular feedback

Performance reviews need to consist the a bike of check-ins and also feedback transparent the year, not just an annual summit. Employees that receive constant feedback are much more likely to remain on track and also to feel their reviews space fair.

4. Train managers

Managers additionally need coaching and also development. Plenty of front-line supervisors are advocated into those location with little experience in power management, yet they"re the structure of her program. Make sure your leaders are equipped to usage your pay program consistently and fairly to drive their teams" performance.

5. Calibrate her pay system

If her pay mechanism is too complex, it will be cumbersome to provide and confusing to employees. Emphasis on a handful of goals to connect to compensation.

Your salary scales and raises likewise need to be finely calibrated: differentiated enough to reward high performance, yet not so broad as to feel unfair.

6. Involve employees

Involving employee in setup goals and also KPIs for your positions urges buy-in to her performance monitoring system. It"s likewise a good strategic exercise.

7. Develop in flexibility

As with any human resource (HR) practice, your system needs sufficient flexibility to allow for manager discretion.

8. Consider different plans

Some companies have imposed innovative change compensation plan in lieu of an easy merit awards. Below are some instances from a recent culture for Human resource Management (SHRM) symposium:

Annual merit raises to add quarterly bonusesSet salary increases based on company-wide performanceNo merit increases, with periodic sector adjustments to pay together warrantedVariable pay based on job level, from 35% to policemans to 8% for assistance staffIncentive awards whenever employee go over and beyond

9. Usage software

Using HR software such as Zoho world to carry out pay and also performance management can save managers and HR staff time on regimen paperwork. That can additionally enhance the accuracy and also fairness of your performance testimonial system. Software renders it straightforward to send out surveys and also gather feedback efficiently.

HR software have the right to also carry out workforce analytics and other insights to educate your salary strategies.

See more: 137 Barton Road Stow Ma 01775 United States, 137 Barton Rd, Stow, Ma 01775

Merit pay has actually its merits

For all the talk around ditching power reviews and also annual merit increases, it"s tough to imagine a device to attach pay v performance the doesn"t depend on some version of this time-tested practices. But those tools room yours to adapt to fit your company"s unique society and goals. The vital is to get input from her staff, look at for brand-new ideas, and keep ~ above tweaking till your system truly serves your employees and your company.