The design template for today’s recap, which must be running v your mental constantly like some relentless stop bearing under the refrain tracks toward you is this:

NINA would certainly NEVER.

You are watching: Project runway season 17 episode 8


*

At the very least that’s what we’re informing ourselves this morning as we shot to grapple through that win. Nina was under the weather and also Karlie had actually a wedding to walk to, i m sorry left us through the an initial truly unbalanced judging panel due to the fact that the show returned come Bravo. That felt weird. There is no Nina there, we had to battle with even if it is we welcomed Brandon, Elaine and also Marni as legitimate stand-ins for she taste and also smoothly proficient reliability.

*


But the reality remains, the judges plainly have a favorite and Nina has certainly been a Hester-booster through many of the season. It’s most likely not too lot of a stretch come think Nina might’ve been on board with this one. Still, that judging conference felt choose we were on Bizarro world.

*

In other news, cracks are beginning to present in the cast’s camaraderie. Tessa has always been fairly opinionated around the work of her competitors, but this week, her rivals decided come return the favor and she wasn’t specifically happy around it. Still, it claims something about the casting of this season that also with emphasize rearing your head, the many these designers might do was obtain a little snippy and passive-agressive around it. And while we can’t to speak Tessa’s always in the right, we additionally can’t blame her for gift a small frustrated by the judging this week. Hester really is gaining wildly over-favored.


*

Otherwise, it to be a reasonably typical illustration of Nu-PR. We assumed the announcement about Karlie and Nina no being ~ above the evaluate panel was interesting, because that type of thing would have been mentioned as an next by Tim (or even not in ~ all) during the old days. The new team is figured out to weave a story through each episode and we type of appreciated the moment they took to phase this announcement. The felt choose they were respecting the designers and also the audience.

As one aside, Karlie. Girl. That’s not your look.


*

We think Marni makes a good addition to the team and also any time she’s consulting in the job-related room, there’s an energy and also savvy to it the really helps the show and also the designers. Having actually said that, she probably shouldn’t it is in a consistent judge. Together a stylist, she’s constantly going come gravitate towards high-personality looks that either border ~ above cray or happily leap over that line. In various other words, she’s an skilled on style however that doesn’t typical she makes the ideal judge that fashion design.


Team Rio HolidaySebastian (Beachwear)

*

It is INSANE the this wasn’t the winning look, permit alone that this wasn’t the winning team. This is stylish, on allude for the quick (unlike so countless others, who thought Morena Baccarin to be going to hit the roadways of Rio with a basket the fruit on her head, while extended in bananas and also macaws), and also actually looks favor something she might wear, based upon our coverage of her format over the years.


Tessa (Daywear)

*

Nice to check out Tessa break out into some bold color. This is okay. The bodice appears a little heavy and also overdone and also the straps under the earlier were way too lot for a work look.

Lela (Eveningwear)

*

Hmm. Okay, fine. Perhaps Sebastian’s to be the best and then his teammates adhered to that up v passably an excellent work. This isn’t one award-winner, but it has a low-key elegance to it, i beg your pardon is very much in line with Morena’s style.

Team CarnivalJamall (Beachwear)

*

WHAT even IS THIS? He’s not just lucky he has immunity, he’s happy Nina wasn’t there since she would certainly have had his head because that this. The idea the a swimdress isn’t unheard-of, however putting all the tulle and also netting between her legs is so bizarre it provides us wonder if he’s got any decent instincts. He really appeared blindsided by the judges’ hate of this.

Renee (Daywear)

*

Oof. Even if us look at those pants and also go, “Poor Renee. She had a negative day,” the doesn’t define or excuse she hideous selections here. Probably we were imagining it, yet we believed Morena was type of pissed around the output this week. So plenty of designers listened come a stylish, elegant woman talk about her return trips come Brazil and wound up making the many hideous tourist garments for her.

Venny (Eveningwear)

*

Cute, yet as noted, far an ext appropriate for a teenager.

Team Disco QueenHester (Beachwear)

*

We totally admit that this is a pretty warm bathing suit. And we think the judges wound up doing that point they often tend to do once they have a pet that made something lock like: castle tossed the short out. Obviously us don’t understand the woman, but it strikes us as an extremely hard to believe that this is something Morena Baccarin would certainly wear ~ above the beach. She simply doesn’t go for loud or over-sexy looks. She’s no someone that does a many body-baring or body-conscious style.

Bishme (Daywear)

*

And we recognize that this is one of the best looks ~ above the runway. We think Sebastian’s is much better, but we suspect component of the factor this team remained in the top was since Morena yes, really did want to wear this.

Garo Sparo (Eveningwear)

*

And yes. Fine. This also has a low-key elegance to it that would certainly appeal come her. We don’t dislike the design, but we walk think the fabric choices didn’t help. Lock don’t watch expensive. Also, us don’t prefer the form of the neckline or the heaviness that the zipper, which really does do this seem choose a day-time cover-up fairly than an night gown.

See more: Br A Projectile Is Fired From A Gun Near The Surface Of Earth

But whatever. The judges love themselves a character and also Hester’s been giving them the in spades. Us don’t dislike her as a designer and also we deserve to see why she’s bubbled as much as front-runner status, but they insanity over-praised her occupational this week. An ext on today’s podcast in a bit.