A an excellent villain is an important for many stories. The rogue is typically the 2nd most essential character, behind just the protagonist themself. If a villain goes wrong, they often drag the entire story down with them, and also there are many ways for villains to go wrong. Due to the fact that depicting villains have the right to be especially complicated for new writers, I view a the majority of these in my volume as a content editor, and also I’d favor to re-superstructure them through you. If you fix these issues early, you deserve to save a many time and money when the hour for editing and enhancing arrives.

You are watching: Nice job fixing it villain

1. Pointless Cruelty

*
Kingpin death an underling he really should have actually left alive because he’s EVIL.

Villains space generally poor people – that’s part of the task – yet sometimes they walk to man extremes to present you simply how negative they are. They’ll absent puppies, twirl their mustaches, and force prisoners to watch the odd-numbered Star Trek movies. It’s all truly horrific, yet there no seem come be any kind of purpose to it.

These villains room being pointlessly cruel. Not only is this clichéd, yet in many stories it damages the audience’s suspension the disbelief. We know that most people don’t act favor cartoon characters, and an over-the-top villain regularly makes a story seem far less credible. In ~ the exact same time, being pointlessly cruel can actually reduce a villain’s hazard level, together it renders them it seems ~ incompetent.

Why This Happens

The most common reason I’ve found is the authors believe they deserve to actually rise the villain’s danger level by making them action cruelly, and there is a tiny bit of fact to that. If the heroes uncover out the the villain is walk to death them quite than imprison them, that raises the stakes. However this technique has conveniently diminishing returns. If the characters currently think they’re going come die, finding the end that the villain will desecrate your corpses afterward doesn’t raise the stakes; it just makes the rogue seem favor a dick.

Alternatively, villains will sometimes communicate in meaningless evil since the storyteller requirements to connect that the villain is bad, yet there isn’t anything plot appropriate for them to carry out yet. If the opened of a story is yes, really slow, the villain can have come eat a kitten-soup instead of creating problems for the hero – otherwise girlfriend won’t understand who the negative guy is!

A 3rd justification storytellers regularly give is that actual life is full of villains who space pointlessly cruel. They view bigoted politicians posting racist tweets there is no a thought and also assume fictitious villains have to act that means too. What this storytellers miss is that such action of cruelty are not pointless at all; they room performative. They room a bigot’s way of signaling to various other bigots, purposely or otherwise. Without the context, such behavior will it seems to be ~ wildly out of place.

How to deal with It

In most cases, the ideal antidote to pointless angry is to make it evil for a purpose. You must construct a plot where the rogue acts cruelly in bespeak to more their goals, no just since the the atmosphere takes them. That way your villain will still be evil, yet it will certainly feel like part of the story rather than an uncomfortable detour.

If you desire your rogue to mirror far-right leaders who blame the victims of fixed shootings for their very own deaths, you have to set up the suitable context. Remember, this no something political leaders do simply for the hell of it. They execute it due to the fact that it it s okay them support from your bigoted constituency. Recreating the context might make your story a little too dark for part audiences, however it will at the very least make sense.

2. Lacking Power

*
In fantastic Beasts, muggles are supposed to threaten wizards even though wizards have all the power.

In this story, the hero has actually the powers of at sight strength, flight, and teleportation. They’re additionally a expert veteran v a dozen years of fighting evil under their belt. Meanwhile, the villain has a herbal talent because that handing the end parking tickets. Lock fight, and the results are predictably one sided.

When the rogue doesn’t have actually the strength to threaten the hero, they absence power. Few things carry the story come a screeching halt choose an underpowered villain, because if the villain isn’t a threat, then why is this story even being told? us all understand the hero is going to win, for this reason there’s no tension, and when they lastly do win, yes no satisfaction. In ~ the same time, if we see the rogue plotting and also scheming to loss a much more powerful hero, we finish up cheering for the bad guy instead.

Why This Happens

Often, storytellers merely miscalculate how powerful a villain is. This is an especially likely as soon as the villain depends on minions for their muscle. Minions deserve to be a powerful advantage, but only if lock effective, and also fiction has a propensity to act them like a young inconvenience. All the minions in the civilization can’t help a villain if the plot is plainly leading towards a climactic fistfight with the hero.

Just as often, writer get brought away with how cool your heroes are. We’ve every been tempted to provide our protagonists too much candy, and extra gibberish powers space sweet indeed. By the time you start to wonder if the story’s gained too sweet, the hero is a living god dealing with the completely mortal villain.

A much less orthodox however just as damaging engine is when the rogue represents miscellaneous the writer finds morally unpalatable, for this reason they don’t want to do the villain seem cool. This concern crops up a lot of in principles stories, wherein the rogue is a stand-in for some political or honest position the author disagrees with.

How to resolve It

When creating a villain, constantly err top top the side of do them an ext powerful. In ~ the begin of the story, they should have the ability to smite the hero in whatever challenge is many relevant come the plot. The way, you obtain the many satisfaction when the hero overcomes this advantage and triumphs. It’s feasible to walk too far with this, however you have a same amount the room before a villain becomes too powerful.

You can likewise make a villain more threatening by changing the kind of dispute in play. If her story is a legitimate battle, it’s feasible that a perfect mundane human lawyer might be a deadly threat to her superpowered hero. However, you have to be cautious that her hero’s an abilities actually no applicable to the conflict. If her hero can intimidate the angry lawyer through super-flexing, then the hero isn’t really an underdog.

Finally, if you find your rogue so morally repugnant that you’re underpowering them, it’s probably time to reframe her story. Use parallels and allegory to produce some distance. Then, you’ll have the ability to create a serviceable villain without fear of empowering the point you hate.

3. Unthreatening Goals

*
In Discovery, Captain Lorca is depicted as angry for wanting much better weapons to defend against room Nazis.

The villain of this story is a genuine jerk. They’re constantly saying rude things to the hero and also implying they have actually sinister plans. Currently the hero is collection on preventing them from doing… something? It’s no actually clear, because the villain is never presented to it is in doing noþeles worse 보다 a menacing cackle.

When a rogue isn’t do the efforts to perform something the the hero needs to stop, that means they have actually unthreatening goals. Sometimes their purposes are known and also they’re totally mundane; various other times, the purposes remain a secret, however the hero decides they should be quit anyway. One of two people way, this robs the story that urgency and also attachment. It’s difficult to treatment if the heroes win once the rogue doesn’t seem to be doing anything worth stopping.

Why This Happens

Most often, unthreatening goals are a result of negative plotting. It turns out the rogue does have actually an evil setup that have to be stopped, however it hasn’t to be revealed yet. This is especially likely in secret plots. To store the story moving, the writer has the hero act together if they already know what the villain is increase to. Then they make the huge reveal and hope nobody noticed the timing. Occasionally this pattern plays out through the villain transforming their purposes rather than revealing what they were all along, yet it has actually the same effect.

On occasions when the villain’s real goals are quiet unthreatening, the usually because the author hasn’t totally examined them. It could seem poor for the rogue to take end the hero’s residence planet, however if that planet is falling into a blackhole and needs to be evacuated anyway, nothing is really changed.

It’s also possible for this trouble to be brought about by a difference in values. If the author follows certain socialist traditions, they can see the opening of a personal coffee franchise as naturally threatening because they see all private enterprise as a risk to the working class. Meanwhile, a fundamentalist Christian storyteller might think it’s a sin for the villain to job-related as a tattoo artist since tattoos space prohibited under specific biblical translations. Neither of these worths is likely to click v the typical reader.

How to solve It

The an initial thing come remember is the a villain goals must be threatening transparent the whole story, both come the hero and also to the audience. If those goals adjust later, it is fine, however they should adjust to something also worse. If you desire to keep those goals mysterious, that have the right to work, but the rogue still has to be act something threatening. The hero could not know why the villain is killing cyborgs and also harvesting your cortical stacks, yet the murder alone is sufficient to carry out plenty the urgency.

When deciding what the villain’s goals are in the very first place, store in mind just how they impact the hero and the hero’s love ones. A an excellent standby is the the villain either desires to do the hero’s life notably worse or at least prevent that from acquiring better. This type of goal fits nicely alongside an ext abstract options like judgment the galaxy, and also it helps store the story grounded.

Goals prefer these are also useful for avoiding problems from value clashes. When you have the right to never be certain what values an median reader will have, most people will instinctively care about threats to the hero or human being the hero care about. If you want to use a an ext niche set of goals, you’ll require to uncover a method to make those goals matter to the median reader.*

4. Preventing Comeuppance

*
In Star Trek: The following Generation, Admiral Haftel gives Data’s daughter one anxiety attack so intense she dies. The feels a tiny bad about it.

By the finish of this story, the villain’s killed a score of chaste people and also harvested your spleens as part of a ritual for ultimate power. Finally, the heroes monitor this vile fiend down, and after a fierce battle they… let the rogue go through a firm talking to? nothing worry, the rogue promises never ever to execute it again!

When a story ends and it feels prefer the villain gained off also easily, they’ve avoided your comeuppance. In ~ best, this pipeline the story with an unsatisfying karma imbalance. Audience want poor things to take place to poor people, and when castle don’t, the irritating. In ~ worst, this type of ending feels like the rogue is simply going to work-related their evil deeds what else, therefore the heroes didn’t actually resolve anything.

Why This Happens

By much the most common reason this happens is that the story takes ar in a setting without a formal system of justice. There’s no jail because that the rogue to be sent to, and the author doesn’t desire to kill them, so instead there’ll it is in a scene wherein the hero tries to intimidate the negative guy into providing up their angry ways. Also if this scene is in which method convincing, which it hardly ever is, the villain is still escaping repercussion free.

I’ve likewise seen stories wherein the author grew to prefer the villain more than any type of other character and also didn’t desire anything negative to take place to them. This is a persistent problem because villains are regularly the most energetic character in a story, for this reason it’s basic to fall for them and even start making excuses because that them. This is especially usual in redemption arc stories. Anyone loves a good redemption, yet not everyone will certainly agree on as soon as the villain has actually actually made amends.

How to resolve It

If her story takes location in a setting without jails, or at the very least without jails that have the right to hold the villain, you require to arrangement what wake up to the poor guy in advance. The easiest solution is because that the villain to die, most likely in a climactic duel with the hero. However, if you’re ready to kill the villain, you more than likely don’t have this difficulty in the very first place.

If you have to keep the villain alive, maybe to use them later, the most vital thing is to do clear the they’re no longer a threat. This requires an ext than a lecture and a promise. They should lose their power, be stripped of their armies, or otherwise calculation impotent. If they’ve been an especially heinous, you’ll more than likely want come arrange part extra punishment for them, probably stuck in a hell dimension for a few years or required to address Seattle web traffic for a couple of days.

Alternatively, you have the right to simply have the villain escape punishment, so lengthy as it’s treated favor a difficulty in the story. The heroes have the right to celebrate their victory, yet they need to acknowledge the the rogue is still the end there, wait to win again. Depending upon how threaten the villain is, this could make a great hook because that the sequel.

In the occasion that you find you prefer a villain too much to let anything take place to them, that’s more than likely a sign that you should revise the story therefore they’re the main character. Girlfriend might be able to resolve the situation with a redemption arc because that the villain, but consider if that’s yes, really the finest course. Is that feasible because that this villain to make amends as component of their arc? If not, you’ll have actually the same difficulty with a absence of satisfaction.

5. Sympathy Mismatch

*
Sometimes Dragon Prince yes, really wants united state to care how Viren feels. Other times the tries to killing children.

The villain of this story is a terrible person. We’ve viewed them feeding innocent people to piranhas and additionally review bomb Captain Marvel without also seeing it. Clearly, this is the scum of humankind we’re managing here. Yet then the story beginning dropping clues that probably the rogue was right all along. That asks us to think about how they check out things. What the heck is walking on here? Why would we treatment what this jerk thinks?

When storytellers shot to humanize a character the audience can not stand, that’s a sympathy mismatch. In order come care about a rogue perspective, the audience demands to have at least some sympathy for them. If the sympathy isn’t present, then any attempts to present the villain in a optimistic light will fall fully flat. They might even do it seem prefer the writer is intentionally endorsing the villain’s heinous actions.

Why This Happens

From what I can glean by talking to authors, one major contributor is the way sympathetic villains are almost worshipped in online discussions around storytelling. Yes a emotion that villains have to be sympathetic, for this reason storytellers often shot to pressure sympathy once there isn’t any.

At the very same time, it’s straightforward for storytellers come forget the they probably know the villain much better than your audience ever will. Readers have only the native on the page, while viewers have actually only dialogue and also the actor’s human body language. Storytellers, ~ above the various other hand, recognize their villain inside and out, understanding every little thing that goes into the character’s decisions. This renders it straightforward to overestimate exactly how sympathetic audience will uncover the villain.

Another big contributor is ours old friend, different values. Some civilization will care about specific things an ext than others, and also it’s straightforward for storytellers to obtain that balance wrong. A storyteller could not think that their villain giving a surprised kiss is a huge deal, but readers who’ve competent them in genuine life might have very different ideas.

How to deal with It

The very first step is expertise that no all villains need to be sympathetic. It’s fine if your negative guy is just bad, through no expedition of their deeper motives or consideration that they might be in reality be right. If her villain is irredeemable, then her audience will certainly happily bask in the satisfaction of their defeat.

If you’re set on offering your villain your sympathetic moment, you need to make sure they haven’t pass what I speak to the moral event horizon. This is the suggest from i beg your pardon there have the right to be no return, even if the villain were to totally change their ways, due to the fact that the audience no longer wants them to be redeemed.

The exact suggest of the moral occasion horizon varies from human being to person, however there are a few things the will virtually certainly put your character end it. Torture is a large one, along with the killing of pets or children. Killing innocent adult is questionable, yet not a great sign. Sexual violence will almost certainly execute it, along with most other hate crimes.

If she hoping because that mitigating circumstances to store your rogue from going over the edge, they have to be yes, really clear. Her villain’s inner grief end a shed loved one no going to cut it. You’ll require to display how they to be pressured into evil action by a cult-like setting or manipulated by a mythological force. Whatever the specifics, it need to be miscellaneous the audience can conveniently identify therefore you understand they’re ~ above the exact same page.

6. Poor Motivation

*
In Star Trek V, Sybok bring away over whole planet in stimulate to obtain a ship, other that’s really straightforward to get in Star Trek.

Our last villain today has actually plans that room truly evil. They want to burn down the rainforests and crash the moon right into the Earth! Why would they do that, you ask? ns guess it is a reasonable question. Lock live ~ above the planet too, and also it’s not clear just how their interests are served by turning it into an unlivable wasteland. I don’t expect you’d accept that they’re simply evil like that?

When that unclear why a villain is law what lock doing, they have insufficient motivation. This is an old cliché, but it’s still very relevant today. Audiences suppose villains to have some sembleance of a reality motivation, and if castle don’t, the story drops apart. Why need to anyone take it the story seriously once the rogue acts like a caricature the humanity?

Why This Happens

The many common cause of insufficient motivation is the the author simply hasn’t fully thought through the rogue plan. In the rush to make the poor guy evil and also threatening, storytellers forget to examine what would happen if the villain actually won. This can also happen once the writer is make the efforts to it is in mysterious, the cause of so plenty of other difficulties on this list. If the villain has actually a an excellent motivation yet it doesn’t seem favor they carry out for many of the story, the audience will be rightfully frustrated.

A an additional cause of insufficient motivation is as soon as authors try to develop a villain who simply wants to watch the world burn. Everyone loves The Dark Knight’s Joker, and also it’s tempting come recreate the chaos clown also in stories whereby he doesn’t fit.

How to deal with It

In most cases, insufficient an ideas can be fixed by examining the villain’s plan and making certain they’re getting something out of it it is worth all the trouble. In many stories, you don’t also have to get in a lot of detail. That usually sufficient to say that the villain’s plan will make them an ext powerful and also that they want power because that power’s sake.

If the villain’s setup will cause problems because that them and everyone else, maybe by blowing up the planet they live on, you’ll must put in an ext work. What’s the villain’s setup for managing the troubles caused by their initial plan? possibly they’ve acquired a secret Mars base wherein they setup to chill together Earth and the moon collide, or possibly they don’t care about their very own safety and are motivated by revenge.

When the problem originates from keeping part of the villain’s setup secret, remember the advice we’ve currently gone over: make it a intended mystery. If the villain’s to plan seem come hurt them together with everyone else, have the heroes ask why the is. Let them investigate. This turns a story’s weakness into a strength.

Finally, if you’re reasoning of do a Joker-type villain who just wants to watch the people burn, think about if that’s really what’s finest for her story. The Joker works because Batman story are heavily themed confrontations between order and also chaos. If your story doesn’t have actually a comparable context, that kind of stylized rogue is likely to autumn flat.

See more: I Got: Raven Queen! Which Ever After High Character Are You, Which Ever After High Character Are You

New stories deserve to have a watch unlimited number of issues that require your attention, yet it’s worth placing in special effort for the villain. A well-executed poor guy offers tension and satisfaction, yet a flopped antagonist can quickly take the story down v them. Your readers will say thanks to you for putting in the extra work.